The New Border

|

I have been crossing the Canadian/American border for 45 years.

As a kid I remember trips to the USA from Canada where standard interviews at border crossings dealt mainly with the subject of where you were going, and how long your visit would be.

In 1966, it didn't matter if you brought a cooler full of ham sandwiches, and fruit, or a beer for a leg-stretch-rest-stop-pit-stop-lunch-stop on your way to your destination.

In the early 70's, I remember my mother buying a TV in Portsmouth for half the cost of what the same model retailed for in Quebec. She arrived at the Canadian Customs on her way back to Montreal, and declared her purchase without having one guard check the contents in the trunk of our car.

Short trips to the States have always led Canadians to tempt fate and find creative ways to bring back cheap purchases without having to go through the scrutiny of border checks and duty fees.

Some people wear no shoes on their feet on their way down. These same people would come back with one new pair in their travel bag and another new pair on their feet. Others would carefully wear several layers of new clothing, or stuff as much as they could into the empty space of their car's spare tire.

For years all you had to do was select and flash a few receipts of trivial purchases and you would be waived on with no questions asked.

9/11 has changed all that.

On the Friday before Labor Day 2002, it took me over three hours to cross the Vermont border into the US. The scrutiny was something I understood. After patiently waiting my turn in an endless line of cars, I knew the world had changed when a border guard spent 15 minutes sifting through the van ahead of me, pulling a pile of luggage apart. He ended up dragging a cooler out onto the pavement and opened it. He quickly reached in, pulled out an orange and threw it into a trash bin.

I sat there wide-eyed, watching this display, and replayed the memories from my youth while coming to terms with a new understanding of the long standing laws that prohibited the transportation of meat, citrus fruit, and potted plants into the United States from Canada.

On Mother's Day 2004 I was living in New Hampshire, and had just received my permanent residency papers. An immigration officer told me I could travel to see my mother, even though I did not have my green card yet.

He was wrong.

I was detained for four hours on my way back to New Hampshire from a nursing home in Montreal because the man in the booth at the border believed my story but could not let me pass because I was supposed to have that piece of plastic with my face on it. I was led to an isolated room where I had to have my picture and fingerprints taken. Then I had to wait for a copy of a report to be written and signed by the only person with the authority to do so once he arrived on his shift.

A few words of advice to those travelling across the world's longest "undefended" border.

Never clown around when asked for your passport.

I had a friend who was an immigrant from Europe smile in the process of handing over his little blue booklet and say, "What? Do I look like a terrorist?"
An hour later he was still parked in front of the Customs office trying to figure out how to replace the panels on his car's doors.

Employ common sense when providing honest answers during your brief interview with stern looking guards from Canada, or the US.

Do not end up like the kid from Pennsylvania who replied to the simple question of "Where are you from?"

The poor kid said, "Mars."

The bus he was on was emptied, and every piece of luggage on it rummaged through before the guards involved realized that there is such a place as Mars, Pennsylvania.

Remember that as of June 1st you will need to dish out $50 to $100 for U.S. State Department cards, or papers to cross into Canada, and back into the States.

The head of our Bureau of Homeland Security is demanding such compliance. Janet Nepolitano and a few members of congress seem to be obsessed with the myth that the 9/11 terrorists crossed into the United States from Canada on that tragic day. After almost eight years these same people still want to blame Canada. They have not realized that the perpetrators did not do so, and even if they did, Canadian border guards are not the ones who process anyone entering the United States.

The new points of entry "parity" posture is just a little confusing to this Canadian expatriot who has to try and understand why immigration laws are still not being enforced upon those who have crossed illegally into this country from the "other" border.

Pardon my cynicism. I guess having spent $30,000 doing things by the book to become an American legally has jaded my attitude toward those who will eventually be offered permission to live in this country after paying a small fine for their deliberate transgression.

One last word of advice. If you plan to travel to, and from Canada this summer, and do not want any hassles at the border, make sure to bring a license, birth certificate, passport, or passport card, and a few motor vehicle friendly renditions of the American flag with you.

A slightly used 2008 Obama/Biden election sticker slapped on your bumper wouldn't hurt, either.

Leave the oranges and ham sandwiches at home.


Ken Braiterman's picture

Borderlines

Excellent column:  well written, funny, useful, and informative.

I'm sure you were not aware that "Borderlines," the way you used it in your headline, is extremely offensive to some people with mental illness and their families. It trivializes the excrutiating pain and fear these people and their loved ones live with every day. 

Borderline personality disorder is a terrifying, life-threatening illness.  Nobody chooses to have it, and it does not respond to psychiatric medication.  Borderline personality is something some people have, that they must work extremely hard to live with.  Calling someone "a borderline" denies the fact that he is a person first, not an illness.

 Even among people with mental illness and the clinicians who treat them, people with borderline personality disorder -- the "borderlines" -- are the most stigmatized group.  They can be impulsive, bad-tempered, and sometimes dangerous to themselves and others until they develop coping skills.  There are programs that do a lot of good for a lot of these unfortunate people, but they take a long time.

We should not insult or marginalize them by calling them "borderlines," because they are not that way because they want to be.


Brian Drummond's picture

Well...Ummmm...Errr....

I was kind of taking a shot at our Head of the Bureau of Homeland Security, and the double standards that take place at our borders to the north and south.

Her ignorance of the facts to the north and inability to act on issues regarding the south.

It was a sarcastic statement and a play on words.

As for metal illness. My wife and I spent years dealing with my mother and her father living with Alzheimer's until they both passed away in 2005.

I apologize if my "reach" for a wordy hook in my title offends anyone.

Regards,

Brian.


Ken Braiterman's picture

Janet Napolitano does not

Janet Napolitano does not have borderline personality diesorder, and BPD has nothing to do with ignorance.  I know peple wih BPD who know a lot more than I do.  Don't apologize for offending people,  You used a life-threatiing disease to crack a mean, insensitive, sarcastic joke.  Do you also crack jokes abut cancer?  It's not that you offended someone.  When you give some indication that you now understand what was really wrong, then I'll accept your apoogy.  Borderline personality disorder is a lot more serious than a  bad pun.


Brian Drummond's picture

?????????????

New title for you Ken.

I apoogicize.


Ken Braiterman's picture

I still can't tell if you've learned why you're apologizing

You trivialized gut-wrenching pain that can be fatal, and turned it into a joke.  You turned people who have BPD into a joke. You still haven't apologiized for that, only for hurting my feelings. 

I need to know you finally understand what a terrible disease BPD is:  that it's not the fault of the victim or his family, that it's not something anyone would choose, that it has nothing to do with a victim's intelligence -- and indicate that you've learned it is nothing to joke about. 

You mentioned your parents with Alzheimer's.  I'm very sorry you and they went through that.  I did with my father too.  Know any good jokes about Alzheimer's, and how would you feel if you heard one?  Would you object and risk being seen as a hypersensitive humorless guy, or just let it go unchallenged?

And what if the person who cracked the joke said, "No offense.  Sorry if I offended you."  What would constitute an acceptable apology to you and everyone else who suffered as you have.

K


Brian Drummond's picture

A Chill Pill For Ken And Another Sorry You Have To Read This...

I'm beginning to worry about your state of mind Ken.

You're focusing on one definition of the word "borderline" of which there are four offered in Merrium-Webster.

You've also lost focus of the content of my blog, so that you can "educate" me in some wierd Janeane Garofalo manner.

I work in Healthcare, Ken. I think I know about BPD.

If you think my bad Janet joke was tasteless, I can only imagine what you think of Denis Miller's sense of humor.

I joke about Alz every day. Why? Because there is a history of Alzheimers, dementia, mental illness, and brain cancer in my family.

5 a.m. Not enough coffee. Attempting to put a wallet in the toaster instead of my back pocket. I'll blame the Alzheimer's.

It's a matter of common sense and context and it's funny.  

So, if you must continue, may I provide some fresh subjects for future assaults and tirades. This one has become redundant.

I'm a Christian who rarely goes to church and I don't believe in flag burning, abortion, gay marriage, illegal immigration, or blaming George Bush for all of my inadequacies.

I'm sorry that my attempts to apologize haven't measured up to your standards.

Forgive me for turning my other cheek and ignoring future criticism.


Ken Braiterman's picture

I'm sorry for going too far

I'm sorry for going too far and over the top.

  I was not completely in my right mind this past week.  I've been sweating out the possibility of kidney caner since Monday when something unexpected turned up on an x-ray.  Two docs told me to see a specialist ASAP, and that turns out to be tomorrow afternoon.  They both think it's cancer, but want a specialist to say for sure.

I've been trying to keep my mind off my mind as much as I can, but it's hard.  Que sera sera, and Let It Be are not really in my vocabulary, and I don't do well in situations that require that attitude.

I'll leave you alone from now on, and I'm very sorry.  You're an excellent writer, and I enjoy your blogs.

 Ken


Scott Ives's picture

Scott Here...

Hi Brian,

Loved the post..it was funny and well written!

Hi Ken,

I am sorry to hear you are going through some difficult times. I will mention you in my prayers and hope for better news!

User login

Brought To You By

Browse archives

« March 2010  
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
 
7 8
15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31